Skip to Main Content

ARTH 282 - Medieval Art and Architecture: Evaluate Sources

Research tips and resources for ARTH 282

Evaluate Sources

Evaluate sources to ensure they're accurate, trustworthy, and appropriate for your research papers.

Evaluating Sources

In addition to ensuring sources are scholarly, consider...

Currency: When was the information created or published? Do you need more current information?

Content: Is the information accurate? Does it provide in-depth information or just a summary?

Viewpoint: How does publication date, publisher or other factors affect viewpoint? How opinionated is the piece?

Relevance:  Is the information important for your needs? Do you need a source to get ideas, or to cite in your paper?

What are Scholarly Sources? - Short Video

Popular, Trade and Scholarly Sources - Short Video

Courtesy of Wayne State University Library

Popular

  • Audience: General
  • Purpose: To entertain, sell products, or share news
  • Format: Short and usually illustrated
  • Sources: Quotes are usually attributed to the speaker, but few sources will be directly credited beyond this

Trade

  • Audience: Professional
  • Purpose: To keep professionals informed about news, trends, and practices in their field
  • Format: Various article lengths with some industry jargon
  • Sources: Quotes and sources are usually given attribution in-text, but are rarely cited separately

Scholarly

  • Audience: Academic
  • Purpose: To inform and advance scholarship
  • Format: Longer format, often with field-specific language and limited illustrations
  • Sources: Scholarly articles always cite their sources in footnotes and/or bibliographies

SIFT Method - Short Video

What is a Scholarly Source?

A scholarly source is an academic book or article written by an expert, reviewed by other experts, published by a scholarly publisher. The purpose of a scholarly source is to inform an audience and advance scholarship. To identify a scholarly source, look for:

  1. Author - expert author in the field
  2. Peer-review - reviewed by other experts before publication
  3. Publisher - academic publisher like a university press or academic journal
  4. Sources - attribution given to the sources referenced by the author

 

Can I use sources that don't meet these criteria?

It depends! Your professor will give you specific instructions about the types of sources you can and cannot use for an assignment. If you are allowed to use non-scholarly sources, it is still important to check that the source is trustworthy. Consider:

  • Who is the author? Are they an expert?
  • Who is the publisher? Is it an established, informative source I can trust?
  • Does it cite sources? Can I trace the information back to it's original creator?
  • How old is it? Has information changed since it was published? Could bias or past beliefs shape the conclusions drawn by the author?
  • What is the purpose? Is it to inform and advance scholarship?